رأی
بار اثبات ادعا و استدلال بر اساس ادله در آرای شعب دیوان عدالت اداری (مقاله علمی وزارت علوم)
بار اثبات ادعا و استدلال بر اساس ادله در آرای شعب دیوان عدالت اداری (مقاله علمی وزارت علوم)
درجه علمی: نشریه علمی (وزارت علوم)
نویسندگان:
علی مشهدی هرمز یزدانی زنوز
منبع:
پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال 26 تابستان 1403 شماره 83
حوزههای تخصصی:
حوزههای تخصصی حقوق حقوق عمومی
doi:
10.22054/qjpl.2023.72337.2872
شماره صفحات:
۱۰۷ - ۱۳۶
دریافت مقاله
تعداد دانلود :
۲۸۶
آرشیو
آرشیو شمارهها:
۵۰
سال ۱۴۰۴ (۴)
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال 27 زمستان 1404 شماره 89
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال 27 پاییز 1404 شماره 88
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال 27 تابستان 1404 شماره 87
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال 27 بهار 1404 شماره 86
سال ۱۴۰۳ (۴)
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال 26 زمستان 1403 شماره 85
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال 26 پاییز 1403 شماره 84
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال 26 تابستان 1403 شماره 83
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال 26 بهار 1403 شماره 82
سال ۱۴۰۲ (۴)
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال 25 زمستان 1402 شماره 81
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال 25 پاییز 1402 شماره 80
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال 25 تابستان 1402 شماره 79
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال 25 بهار 1402 شماره 78
سال ۱۴۰۱ (۴)
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیست و چهارم زمستان 1401 شماره 77
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیست و چهارم پاییز 1401 شماره 76
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیست و چهارم تابستان 1401 شماره 75
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیست و چهارم بهار 1401 شماره 74
سال ۱۴۰۰ (۴)
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیست و سوم زمستان 1400 شماره 73
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیست و سوم پاییز 1400 شماره 72
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیست و سوم تابستان 1400 شماره 71
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیست و سوم بهار 1400 شماره 70
سال ۱۳۹۹ (۴)
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیست و دوم زمستان 1399 شماره 69
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیست و دوم پاییز 1399 شماره 68
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیست و دوم تابستان 1399 شماره 67
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیست و دوم بهار 1399 شماره 66
سال ۱۳۹۸ (۴)
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیست و یکم زمستان 1398 شماره 65
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیست و یکم پاییز 1398 شماره 64
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیست و یکم تابستان 1398 شماره 63
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیست و یکم بهار 1398 شماره 62
سال ۱۳۹۷ (۴)
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیستم زمستان 1397 شماره 61
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیستم پاییز 1397 شماره 60
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال بیستم تابستان 1397 شماره 59
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال نوزدهم بهار 1397 شماره 58
سال ۱۳۹۶ (۴)
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال نوزدهم زمستان 1396 شماره 57
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال نوزدهم پاییز 1396 شماره 56
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال نوزدهم تابستان 1396 شماره 55
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال هجدهم بهار 1396 شماره 54
سال ۱۳۹۵ (۴)
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال هجدهم زمستان 1395 شماره 53
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال هجدهم پاییز 1395 شماره 52
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال هجدهم تابستان 1395 شماره 51
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال هفدهم بهار 1395 شماره 50
سال ۱۳۹۴ (۴)
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال هفدهم زمستان 1394 شماره 49
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال هفدهم پاییز 1394 شماره 48
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال هفدهم تابستان 1394 شماره 47
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال شانزدهم بهار 1394 شماره 46
سال ۱۳۹۳ (۴)
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال شانزدهم زمستان 1393 شماره 45
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال شانزدهم پاییز 1393 شماره 44
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال شانزدهم تابستان 1393 شماره 43
- پژوهش حقوق عمومی سال شانزدهم بهار 1393 شماره 42
سال ۱۳۹۱ (۲)
- پژوهش حقوق سال چهاردهم تابستان 1391 شماره 37
- پژوهش حقوق سال چهاردهم بهار 1391 شماره 36
چکیده
نظر به برخورداری اداره از امتیاز قدرت عمومی؛ در نظارت قضایی، قاعده «البینه علی من ادعی» باید به نفع شهروندِ شاکی تعدیل شود. هر شهروندی که در دیوان عدالت اداری شکایت می نماید الزاما مدعی نیست، بلکه ممکن است ابتدا با اتهامی دایر بر تخلف از سوی اداره مواجه شده باشد. در این موارد، مدعیِ واقعی اداره است. لذا نهادنِ بار اثبات تماماً بر دوش شهروند، تناسبی با اهداف دادرسی اداری نخواهد داشت. بعلاوه، رای دادگاه باید متضمن استدلال بر اساس ادله طرفین و ادله اکتسابی شعبه دیوان باشد. پرسش این است: در رویه دیوان عدالت اداری توزیع بار اثبات ادعا بین طرفین به چه نحو است؟ همچنین آرای صادره از حیث مستدل بودن چه وضعیتی دارند؟ در این تحقیق، تعدادی از آرای شعب دیوان عدالت اداری از حیث توزیع بار اثبات ادعا و همچنین از حیث مستدل بودن مورد بررسی قرار گرفته اند. نتایج حاصله نشان می دهند که بار اثبات ادعا بر دوش شهروند سنگینی می کند و مراحل استدلال بر اساس ادله نیز در متن اکثر آرای مورد بررسی، تمام و کمال قید نشده است.
The Burden of Proof and Evidence-Based Reasoning in the Decisions of the Administrative Court of Justice
Introduction
The admission of evidence and the burden of proving a claim are crucial elements in asserting rights in any legal proceeding, including the administrative proceeding. Judicial supervision serves specific objectives that the administrative proceeding must align with. Given the disparity in power between citizens and administrative bodies, the admission of evidence in administrative proceedings should be facilitated in favor of citizens. Moreover, that the burden of proof rests with the claimant is a principle that should be adjusted in favor of citizens, and the court should accurately identify the true claimant party. Furthermore, the court’s decisions should be supported by evidence-based reasoning. During proceedings, both parties present their evidence, and the judge should actively seek additional evidence when required. Merely reflecting the conclusion of reasoning in the court’s decision falls short of characterizing the decision as evidence-based. In this respect, the present study aimed to examine a number of decisions by the Administrative Court of Justice concerning the distribution of the burden of proof, the judge’s active approach in seeking evidence, and the incorporation of reasoning process in the decisions. The study tried to address the following research questions: How is the burden of proof distributed between the parties during court proceedings? And to what extent are the issued decisions based on evidence?
Literature Review
A review of the related literature revealed a Persian-language article titled “Critical Analysis of Consideration of Evidence in the Administrative Court of Justice” (Mohsenzadeh, 2018), which investigated the issue of evidence in the Administrative Court of Justice.
Materials and Methods
Using a library research method, the present study analyzed the textual content of decisions issued by various branches of the Administrative Court of Justice.
Results and Discussion
Not every citizen who files a complaint in the Administrative Court of Justice is necessarily the claimant; they may have initially been accused of a violation by the administration. In such instances, the administration is the actual claimant, despite the citizen initiating the legal complaint. Moreover, when the administration fails to fulfill its legal obligations, the plaintiff citizen is burdened with proving the nullity in the lawsuit. Therefore, imposing the burden of proof on the citizen is not commensurate with the objectives of administrative proceedings.
In instances where the administration accuses a citizen of a violation and issues a decision or some kind of punishment based on that accusation, the administration should provide clear and compelling evidence—as imposing punishment necessitates incontrovertible proof. Put differently, by assessing evidence presented by both parties with a margin of 51% favoring the administration and 49% favoring the citizen, one cannot subject the citizen to penalties such as fines, building demolitions, or the revocation of business licenses. In cases where there is no punishment for the citizen, the administration must be held accountable, providing a rationale for its actions and decisions. Consequently, the burden of proof cannot be placed on the citizen making the claim as practiced in civil lawsuits, but rather it is necessary that the judge get actively involved in seeking evidence.
In administrative proceedings, most documents are under the control of the administration, leaving citizens without access to them. It is thus becomes incumbent upon the judge to request those documents from the administration and thoroughly examine them. In administrative proceedings, the judge must not adopt a passive stance, merely accepting the evidence presented by the involved parties. Instead, they should take an active role in seeking out evidence pertinent to different aspects of the case. Furthermore, if necessary, the judge should delegate the investigation to judicial officers or refer the matter to an expert.
Act on Organizations and Procedures of the Administrative Court of Justice addresses this need in Article (7) by considering the referral of matters to experts, as well as in Article (41), which predicts any investigation and the use of judicial officers for such purposes. Additionally, Article (44) grants judges the authority to demand documents from the administration. These articles underscore the imperative for judges to get actively involved in seeking evidence and to leverage these capabilities to uncover the truth and establish certainty in administrative proceedings. These legal provisions are designed to create balance and empower citizens, who often find themselves in a disadvantaged position against administrative bodies wielding public power. Therefore, it is of paramount importance to use such legal provisions in administrative proceedings to safeguard the rights of citizens.
Additionally, the court’s decision must be accompanied by evidence-based reasoning. A reasoned judgment includes the evidence presented by both parties. Moreover, the judge shall be tasked with determining what evidence is the most powerful and persuasive and why. The judge should clearly state both the premises of reasoning and the conclusion in the final verdict. Merely using phrases such as according to the contents of the case and the arguments expressed, followed by the conclusion, does not meet the criteria of evidence-based, valid judgment. Judges must not merely rely on the reasoning process as it goes on in their minds, nor is it sufficient to simply state the conclusion. Instead, they must incorporate the premises, the reasoning, and the conclusion in the final decision.
Conclusion
The findings indicate that the burden of proving the claim weighs heavily on the citizen. The judge, however, rarely exhibited the requisite level of diligence in seeking evidence and leveraging the provisions outlined in Articles (7), (41), and (44) of Act on Organizations and Procedures of the Administrative Court of Justice. It was also found that the reasoning process underlying the court’s decisions was not clearly articulated in the decisions.
تبلیغات
موارد مرتبط
برای این صفحه موردِ مرتبطی ثبت نشده.
