رأی
ترسیم گستره ی «تفسیر به عدالت» در حقوق جزا در پرتو منطق حقوق کیفری (مقاله علمی وزارت علوم)
ترسیم گستره ی «تفسیر به عدالت» در حقوق جزا در پرتو منطق حقوق کیفری (مقاله علمی وزارت علوم)
درجه علمی: نشریه علمی (وزارت علوم)
نویسندگان:
محمد امینی حسن پوربافرانی محمدمهدی الشریف مهدی شهابی
منبع:
پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال 14 پاییز و زمستان 1402 شماره 2 (پیاپی 28)
حوزههای تخصصی:
حوزههای تخصصی حقوق حقوق جزا و جرم شناسی
doi:
10.22124/jol.2024.24689.2388
شماره صفحات:
۳۹ - ۵۱
دریافت مقاله
تعداد دانلود :
۳۹۷
آرشیو
آرشیو شمارهها:
۳۲
سال ۱۴۰۴ (۲)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال 16 پاییز و زمستان 1404 شماره 2 (پیاپی 32)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال 16 بهار و تابستان 1404 شماره 1 (پیاپی 31)
سال ۱۴۰۳ (۲)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال 15 پاییز و زمستان 1403 شماره 2 (پیاپی 30)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال 15 بهار و تابستان 1403 شماره 1 (پیاپی 29)
سال ۱۴۰۲ (۲)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال 14 پاییز و زمستان 1402 شماره 2 (پیاپی 28)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال 14 بهار و تابستان 1402 شماره 1 (پیاپی 27)
سال ۱۴۰۱ (۲)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال سیزدهم پاییز و زمستان 1401 شماره 2 (پیاپی 26)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال سیزدهم بهار و تابستان 1401 شماره 1 (پیاپی 25)
سال ۱۴۰۰ (۲)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال دوازدهم پاییز و زمستان 1400 شماره 2 (پیاپی 24)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال دوازدهم بهار و تابستان 1400 شماره 1 (پیاپی 23)
سال ۱۳۹۹ (۲)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال یازدهم پاییز و زمستان 1399 شماره 2 (پیاپی 22)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال یازدهم بهار و تابستان 1399 شماره 1 (پیاپی 21)
سال ۱۳۹۸ (۲)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال دهم پاییز و زمستان 1398 شماره 2 (پیاپی 20)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال دهم بهار و تابستان 1398 شماره 1 (پیاپی 19)
سال ۱۳۹۷ (۲)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال نهم پاییز و زمستان 1397 شماره 2 (پیاپی 18)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال نهم بهار و تابستان 1397 شماره 1 (پیاپی 17)
سال ۱۳۹۶ (۲)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال هشتم پاییز و زمستان 1396 شماره 2 (پیاپی 16)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال هشتم بهار و تابستان 1396 شماره 1 (پیاپی 15)
سال ۱۳۹۵ (۲)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال هفتم پاییز و زمستان 1395 شماره 2 (پیاپی 14)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال هفتم بهار و تابستان 1395 شماره 1 (پیاپی 13)
سال ۱۳۹۴ (۲)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال ششم پاییز و زمستان 1394 شماره 2 (پیاپی 12)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال ششم بهار و تابستان 1394 شماره 1 (پیاپی 11)
سال ۱۳۹۳ (۲)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال پنجم پاییز و زمستان 1393 شماره 2 (پیاپی 10)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال پنجم بهار و تابستان 1393 شماره 1 (پیاپی 9)
سال ۱۳۹۲ (۲)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال چهارم پاییز و زمستان 1392 شماره 2 (پیاپی 8)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال چهارم بهار و تابستان 1392 شماره 1 (پیاپی 7)
سال ۱۳۹۱ (۲)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال سوم پاییز و زمستان 1391 شماره 2 (پیاپی 6)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال سوم بهار و تابستان 1391 شماره 1 (پیاپی 5)
سال ۱۳۹۰ (۲)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال دوم پاییز و زمستان 1390 شماره 2 (پیاپی 4)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال دوم بهار و تابستان 1390 شماره 1 (پیاپی 3)
سال ۱۳۸۹ (۲)
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال اول زمستان 1389 شماره 2
- پژوهشنامه حقوق کیفری سال اول پاییز 1389 شماره 1
چکیده
عدالت و نیل به آن از مهم ترین خواسته ها ی بشریت است و امید به تحقق آن نزد مرجع قضائی بیش از هرجای دیگری است. شهروندان به درستی می خواهند تا قانون، عادلانه و برای همه افراد اجرا شود، اما روشن است که در بسیاری از موارد، اجرای عادلانه قانون، در گرو تفسیر عادلانه است. پرسش اصلی مقاله ی حاضر آن است که آیا در حقوق کیفری نیز می توان سخن از تفسیر به عدالت داشت و منطق حقوق کیفری، مجوز انجام چنین تفسیری را می دهد؟ فرضیه مقاله آن است که در حقوق کیفری و در پرتو منطق حقوقی آن، می توان تفسیر به عدالت (عدالت گرایانه) از قوانین مربوطه داشت، اما تفسیرگر در این مسیر باید از ظرفیت های عادلانه ا ی نظیر اصول تفسیر قوانین کیفری که در قانون اساسی، قوانین عادی یا حتی دکترین، نسبت به آن ها تصریح شده، استفاده کند و براین اساس نمی تواند از تعبیر «تفسیر به عدالت» به طور مستقل و برای انجام تفسیری سلیقه ا ی بهره برد.
Drawing the scope of "Justice-based interpretation" in Criminal Law in the Light of the Logic of Criminal Law
Justice is one of the most important demands of humanity, and the hope of realizing it is more in the courts than anywhere else. Citizens expect the statute to be implemented fairly and for all people, but it is known among jurists that in many cases, the fair implementation of the statute depends on a fair interpretation. While justice-based interpretation has been a topic of discourse in civil law, this article probes into the possibility of extending its applicability to criminal law.? Despite the superior principles of interpretation in criminal law (such as the principle of narrow interpretation, interpretation for the benefit of the accused, etc.), the question arises: Can justice-based interpretation find a place within the logical framework of criminal law? If the answer is positive, what are the conditions of justice-based interpretation in criminal law? The article hypothesizes that in criminal law and the light of its legal logic, it is possible to have a justice-based interpretation of the relevant statutes, but in this direction, the judge must use fair capacities such as the principles of interpretation of criminal statutes that are in the constitution and ordinary statutes or even doctrine opinions The article asserts that the expression “justice-based interpretation” should not be invoked independently and for a subjective interpretation. Introduction In the interpretation of civil and criminal statutes, practical and well-known principles such as the principle of citing authentic jurisprudential sources in civil matters, the principles of the legality of crime and punishment, and narrow interpretation in criminal laws are used by judges and jurists and even in some cases the opinions of the courts with Citations are issued based on these principles. But another method of interpretation, called interpretation-based justice, can be proposed and investigated. The purpose of this kind of interpretation is for the interpreter to reach a fair conclusion by scrutinizing the apparent meaning of the statute and supporting the person who is subject to the statute. Justice-based interpretation has been mostly discussed in civil law; therefore, the main question of this article is whether justice-based interpretation is applicable in criminal law as well. If we consider such an interpretation method acceptable in criminal law, it should be examined whether the way and scope of justice-based interpretation are the same in each civil and criminal law. Alternatively, if there are similarities, there may also be differences between them. MethodologyThe research method in this article is descriptive-analytical, with data collected from library sources. Results and DiscussionFirst, it should be noted that in civil law, there are two different approaches to interpreting the statute (law). According to one approach and considering the inherent validity of the statute and its independent identity, what is important in the interpretation is the correctness of the result, not its fairness, and the correctness of the result depends on compliance with the statute (even if the result of the interpretation is not fair). But in The other approach, Although the statute is accepted as the most important source of law and it is necessary to respect it, the jurist is Still obedient and subservient to the statute, but in the name of justice, he wishes for his ideal to become statute. At the time of interpreting the statute, the jurist should interpret it in such a way that at least a part of the justice and the desired interest is observed, and therefore the interpreter of the statute should find a way the influence justice into the government system instead of looking for the will of the legislator.The interpretation based on justice in criminal law can be either subjective and absolute or systematic and objective.Important foundations for absolute justice in interpretation include 'trust in the interpreter' and the 'personality of the interpreter' which ensures the fairness of his interpretation. Although both bases are independent, they are not unrelated to each other. However, in the approach to absolute-based justice interpretation, discussing the logic of criminal law seems like baseless words, because the logic of law is a systematic matter and to achieve it, one should get help from related tools.However, discussing justice-based interpretation in the context of the logic of criminal law is possible when the judge and the interpreter employ the capacities of legal justice and superior principles of interpretation in criminal law. In the systematic and objective approach of interpretation-based justice, to perform a fair interpretation, other interpretive principles should be used and considering interpretation-based justice independent, as a separate interpretive tool and used by the judge to issue judgments, for criminal rights and to reach The valuable goals pursued in this field will be very dangerous and the interpreters of criminal law must pay attention to this important issue. ConclusionsThe judge cannot give a verdict of guilt by making an extensive interpretation of the behavior that there is doubt about its criminality. If there is ambiguity in aiding a criminal from an institution favoring the accused, the judge and interpreter cannot interpret such ambiguity to the detriment of the accused and deprive him of such an institution, although the judge in both cases, considers his interpretation as the interpretation-based justice. In other words, in the interpretation of criminal laws and especially in the cases of imposing punishment, it is not logical to rely on concepts such as the spirit of the law, the will of the legislator, and the interpretation related justice based on trust in the judge or his moral and scientific characteristics. Interpretation-based justice should be done within the framework of a fair system that contains the principles and rules of interpretation of criminal laws. Otherwise, no obstacle can prevent the numerous and subjective interpretation theories that may limit the rights and freedoms of citizens.The logic of criminal law emphasizes the important point that if interpretation-based justice wants to have a place to appear in criminal law, it must be used within and along with other interpretive principles and has no way to act independently. Selection of ReferencesAkbari, Z; Ardabili, M A; Ashuri, M & Mehra, N (2022), Indicators of Judicial Action in Iran's Criminal Justice System Based on Jurisprudential Teachings, Journal of Comparative Criminal Jurisprudence, 2 (2), p 51-63 [In Persian].Al-Sharif, M Mahdi (2019), Logic of Law, 5th edition, Tehran: Sahami Enteshar Publishing [In Persian].Omidi, J (2018), interpretation of criminal laws, first edition, Tehran: Mizan [In Persian].Pourbafrani, Hassan (2023), special criminal law (Offences against the security of the state & Public Tranquility), fifth edition, Tehran: Jungle Publishing [In Persian].Qiyasi, J (2018). Method of interpretation of criminal laws. second edition. Qom: Bostan Kitab Publishing [In Persian].Katouzian, N (2006), "The contribution of justice in the interpretation of the law", Journal of the Faculty of Law and Political Science, Volume 72 [In Persian].Keiwanfar, Sh (2019), Philosophical Foundations of Law Interpretation, 2nd edition, Tehran: Mizan Publishing [In Persian].Cornell, Drucilla; Rosenfeld, Michel; Gray Carlson, David (1993), Deconstruction and the Possibility of Justice, 1st Ed, Pub: New York.
تبلیغات
موارد مرتبط
برای این صفحه موردِ مرتبطی ثبت نشده.
